The Boy Next Door: Fear Street by R.L. Stine

Lauren and Crystal think Scott has it all.

He’s handsome, he’s the new star of Shadyside High’s football team, and he’s moved in right next door. Now, both girls will do, say, and try anything to get the chance to go out with him. That’s all either of them want.

But that’s all Scott’s last girlfriend wanted too—and now she’s dead.